Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim
against Best Buy Co., Inc. and BestBuy.com, LLC
Affidavit of:
, ,
In , I purchased videogame(s) on Best Buy’s website www.BestBuy.com. As required by Best Buy, I supplied my full name, billing address and email address to complete the purchase.
In violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2710 (“VPPA”), Best Buy knowingly disclosed to third parties, including but not limited to Rokt, the title(s) of the videogame(s) I purchased as well as my personally identifying information, including but not limited to my first name, last name, email address and zip code.
The VPPA prohibits video tape service providers, such as Best Buy, from disclosing the video tape rental or sales records of their customers to third parties without the express written consent of the customer.
I have never given Best Buy consent to disclose my personally identifying information and the names of the videogames I purchased to third parties.
I seek statutory damages of $2,500, reasonable attorneys’ fees, filing fees, litigation costs and punitive damages in an amount to be determined by the court, and any other preliminary and equitable relief the court determines to be appropriate, as authorized by the VPPA. 18 U.S.C. § 2710(c)(2)(A)-(D).
I declare under penalty of perjury that everything I have stated in this document is true and correct.
Date: November 6, 2026
/s/ Jennifer H. Gelman
Name: Jennifer H. Gelman
Date of Birth: The Bruno Firm, LLC
Phone: 205 N. Michigan Avenue, Suite 810
Email: Chicago, IL 60601
(312) 321-6481
Signed in: , jg@brunolawus.com
ATTORNEY-CLIENT RETAINER AGREEMENT
This Attorney-Client Agreement (“Agreement”) is between (“You” or “Your”) and The Bruno Firm, LLC and Don Bivens PLLC (together the “Firms”, “We”, “Us”, or “Our”). If You have questions about this Agreement, please contact Us at bbinfo@donbivens.com or 602-762-2661.
- Scope of Representation.
We will serve jointly as Your attorneys in connection with potential claims You may have against Best Buy, Co., Inc., BestBuy.com, LLC, and other related parties, including parent companies, subsidiaries, and affiliates (“Defendant”, “Best Buy”, or “Company”) for damages that You have suffered as a result of Best Buy’s wrongful acts or omissions. We will represent You to the best of Our ability and according to Our professional and ethical duties as Your attorneys. You acknowledge that We may also associate with other counsel in connection with Your claim.
Upon Your signing of this Agreement, We will represent You in claims against Best Buy relating to Best Buy’s unlawful disclosures in violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act (“VPPA”). You also authorize Us to represent You in related claims against the Company that We may discover and determine are feasible for Us to pursue on Your behalf. We do not represent You in any other matters unless We sign a separate agreement governing those matters. By executing this document, You affirm that You currently are or previously were a Best Buy customer. If We determine that You do not have a valid claim, We will so advise You and this Agreement shall terminate.
You authorize Us to take all actions that We reasonably believe are necessary to pursue Your claim, including but not limited to preparing and signing legal documents, sending a demand letter on Your behalf to Best Buy, filing Your claim in an appropriate court or in an arbitration proceeding, obtaining documents from the Company or third parties to evaluate and prosecute Your claim and negotiating a settlement. We will act in Your best interest at all times.
You also hereby elect to waive Your participation in a class action settlement that would otherwise include Your claim(s). You further consent to the Firms executing an opt-out form on Your behalf in any class action settlement, or, if there is no class action settlement for which preliminary approval or final approval has been granted, to give notice to the court that You have elected to opt-out of the class action. You acknowledge that You retain the right to revoke this waiver at any time after providing written notice through the contact method provided to You.
That said, in the event that We determine it is in Your best interest to prosecute Your claim by a class action, You authorize Us to take the necessary steps to prosecute Your claim as part of a class action.
The outcome of disputed legal matters is always uncertain. You acknowledge that We cannot guarantee that Your claim will be successful or that You will recover any money or obtain any other form of relief.
If a judge, arbitrator or other fact finder does not rule in Your favor, We will evaluate the possibility of appealing the decision if an appeal is allowed. However, We may determine in Our sole discretion not to pursue such an appeal. If We determine not to proceed with an appeal, We will notify You so that You may protect any appeal rights You might have independently.
- Attorneys’ Fees, Expenses, and Fund Disbursement.
You will not owe Us any attorneys’ fees unless We successfully collect a financial recovery for You by payment of an award or settlement of Your claim. You will never owe Us any sums out of pocket for fees or expenses.
In calculating the Firms’ total compensation for any recovery, judgment, or settlement, the Firms may elect to receive any of the following, in their sole discretion:
(a) A contingency fee of forty percent (40%) of the Gross Recovery (defined below) and return of litigation costs and expenses;
(b) If specifically designated in a settlement or judgment, all attorneys’ fees, costs, and expenses (collectively, “Litigation Expenditures”);1 or
(c) All amounts of a Gross Recovery in excess of the full per-client statutory damages to which You may be entitled under applicable law (currently $2,500 per violation under the VPPA).2
______________________________
1 Even though You will pay nothing to Us unless there is a gross recovery, some state laws require that We disclose to You Our regular hourly rates. The hourly rates for the attorneys and other professional staff who may work on Your case range from $250.00 for junior staff to $1,200.00 for senior partners, but You are not responsible to pay Us according to these hourly rates. If We seek Our attorneys’ fees directly from the Company, We will seek them using these hourly rates. You are not billed on an hourly basis and You do not owe Us any attorneys’ fees unless We succeed on Your claim. We reserve the right to update these rates with sixty (60) days’ written notice.
2 For any judgment or settlement that does not separately designate or award attorneys’ fees, costs, or expenses, amounts in excess of the applicable per-client statutory damages shall be deemed to include compensation for the Firms’ attorneys’ fees, costs, and expenses.
If We receive a lump sum amount from the Company for a group of clients with similar claims to Yours, You expressly authorize us to equitably apportion it amongst all clients that We represent. You acknowledge that this fee is the result of an arms-length transaction between You and Us.
You expressly authorize Us to endorse on Your behalf any checks We receive in any claim or case brought under this Agreement that are jointly payable to You and one or more of Us for deposit into Our Interest on Lawyers’ Trust Account (IOLTA).
A. Contingency Fee
As Our fee in this matter, the Firms may elect to receive forty percent (40%) of the Gross Recovery3 as well as the reimbursement of litigation costs and expenses actually incurred. If,
______________________________
3 “Gross Recovery” includes anything of value obtained in connection with this representation, including but not limited to, all monies and other consideration recovered in connection with this representation, including but not limited to settlement proceeds, compensatory, recessionary, and all other damages, restitution, interest, and Litigation Expenditures. For the avoidance of doubt, the inclusion of Litigation Expenditures in this definition of gross recovery is for purposes of calculating the contingency-fee floor under subsection (a) of this section and does not limit the Firms’ right to recover amounts deemed attributable to Litigation Expenditures under subsections (b) or (c) of this section.
however, the law in Your state limits the contingent fees to less than 40%, we will reduce Our fee to the maximum amount allowed under law. If You have any questions about the fee amounts that apply to Your state, please contact Us (though we cannot offer legal advice on this agreement).
After Our fees are deducted, We will then deduct expenses from Your gross recovery. These expenses can include expenses specific to the resolution of Your individual claim, as well as shared expenses advanced on behalf of all Our clients with similar cases for the benefit of the whole group. Common expenses include fees for copying, messenger services, travel, and similar administrative costs, as well as payments to vendors, arbitrators, experts, settlement distribution professionals, or other third-parties who assist in the claim process. All such expenses are billed at cost. If there is a gross recovery, settlement, or judgment in Your favor, We will inform You with a detailed written accounting of the expenses deducted from Your recovery, including a breakdown of each expense.
The Firms assume joint responsibility for this representation. If successful, the Firms have agreed that any award of attorney’s fees will be divided 75% to The Bruno Firm, LLC and 25% to Don Bivens PLLC. You will not be charged any additional fees because there is more than one law firm on the case. The Bruno Firm, LLC will serve as lead counsel in your representation with principal responsibility for strategic decisions. Don Bivens, PLLC has played a larger role in marketing and vetting qualified clients and claims. Don Bivens, PLLC will also advise The Bruno Firm, LLC in all major aspects of your representation, including filing your claim, motions, discovery, mediations, settlement discussions and, if necessary, arbitration of your claim. Both Firms consider the equal division of attorneys’ fees to be reasonable in light of their respective responsibilities and in light of the need to represent you competently and diligently. You consent to this division of fees as being reasonable.
B. Litigation Expenditures
There may be laws that apply to Your claim or provisions of Your agreement with the Company that allow a court or arbitrator to order the Company to pay Litigation Expenditures if Your claim is successful. If these laws or contract provisions apply, You authorize Us to seek the recovery of Litigation Expenditures directly from the Company.
We will only pursue Litigation Expenditures from the Company if Your claim is successful. To the extent the Firms elect to recover Litigation Expenditures in lieu of a contingency fee award, all Litigation Expenditures recovered shall belong exclusively to the Firms.
C. Amounts in Excess of Full Statutory Damages
The VPPA permits an award of statutory damages of $2,500 per violation. To the extent any settlement, judgment, or other recovery results in an award to You in excess of $2,500 per violation, and such settlement, judgment, or other recovery does not specifically designate which portion of the Gross Recovery should be treated as Litigation Expenditures, all amounts in excess
of the full statutory damages to which you may be entitled ($2,500 per violation) shall be treated as Litigation Expenditures. Under such circumstances, the Firms may elect to recover those Litigation Expenditures as if they were separately designated and in lieu of the contingency fee award.
* * *
If there is recovery or settlement in this case, You authorize Us to receive any funds resulting from the settlement award, deduct Our fees and expenses, and send You the remaining amount as soon as practicable. If We are unable to locate You or an authorized representative within ninety (90) days after attempting to distribute Your funds, We may either hold such funds in escrow or deposit them with a tribunal of competent jurisdiction. In the event You do not elect how to receive Your settlement award, You agree that We may disburse Your funds via an electronic method, such as debit or credit card, to the email address We have on file for You. You understand that We may have a lien upon any amount recovered on Your behalf for unpaid fees and expenses.
- Settlement Offers.
You have the right to accept or reject any settlement offer the Company makes to You. We will not settle Your claim without Your express consent.
You give Us exclusive authorization to negotiate settlements with the Company, including as part of a group settlement with other similar claims, and to make decisions about prosecution or settlement tactics on Your behalf. You give Us the right to reject any settlement offer that is not equal to Your actual loss, or the maximum allowable damages, whichever is greater, unless We reasonably believe that We have achieved the likely best settlement possible under the circumstances. If We present You with a settlement offer from the Company, the final decision on whether to accept the offer is Yours. We may provide Our professional opinion on whether the settlement is fair and reasonable. If You decide not to follow Our advice and reject the settlement that we believe to be in Your best interest, We reserve the right to withdraw as Your counsel after giving You reasonable notice of our intent to withdraw as Your attorneys consistent with the applicable professional and ethics rules regarding withdrawal.
You can substitute another law firm for Us as Your attorneys at any time; however, if You do not do so for good cause and You later obtain a settlement, recovery, or judgment, You agree that We are entitled to an amount up to and including the full fee contemplated by this Agreement for legal services rendered. Alternatively, if You substitute another law firm for Us for good cause, or if We withdraw as counsel and You later obtain a settlement, recovery, or judgment, You agree to pay Us reasonable fees and expenses for legal services rendered prior to substitution or withdrawal. The amount of such fees will be determined based on the reasonable value of the work performed and the expenses incurred on Your behalf.
- Multiple Clients; Apportionment of Recovery; and Conflicts of Interest.
You acknowledge that You are not the only client We are representing with respect to this claim and that conflicts of interest could arise between You and Our other clients.
You are one of multiple plaintiffs or claimants being represented by Us with respect to this case. We may reach a single aggregate settlement of multiple claims involving the same or similar factual patterns if We reasonably believe it to be fair and adequate for the group as a whole. In the event that You do not withdraw from the settlement, You authorize Us to apportion the common expenses and recovery between all of Our clients in such manner as We determine to be fair and equitable.
You acknowledge that representation of multiple clients may give rise to potential conflicts of interest. If We believe that such a conflict exists that materially affects Our ability to represent You, We shall discuss the matter with You. If it becomes necessary for Us to withdraw due to such conflict, You may need to obtain new, separate counsel, which could result in additional expenses and delay as the new attorneys become familiar with Your case. If We withdraw from representing You due to a conflict, You agree to waive any objection to Our continued representation of other clients in this matter, provided that We maintain the confidentiality of Your information and comply with all applicable ethical rules regarding conflicts of interest.
- When We May Withdraw as Your Attorneys.
We may withdraw from Our representation of You under specific circumstances, including but not limited to:
- You fail to comply with any portion of this Agreement;
- You fail to cooperate with Us in the prosecution of Your claim, such as failing to respond to Our requests for information in a timely or complete matter;
- You don’t follow Our advice regarding Your case;
- It is not economically viable for You or Us to continue prosecuting Your claim;
- After reviewing Your records or other information, We believe that proving or prosecuting Your claim will be extremely difficult or expensive;
- We determine that further prosecution of the case would be unethical or result in a conflict of interest; or
- The Company enters bankruptcy or liquidation, or We determine that any judgment or recovery would be uncollectible.
We will provide You with reasonable notice prior to withdrawing from the representation. Subject to the requirements of any applicable law or ethics code, such withdrawal will be effective by sending You an electronic notification to Your last known email address.
- Client Duties.
You have certain responsibilities as a client, including responsibilities to keep Us updated with Your contact information, responding promptly to Our communications, and providing true and accurate information and documents necessary for Your claim.
You agree to notify Us of any change in address, telephone, or other contact information by contacting Us in writing. You agree to respond promptly to Our requests for information or documents necessary to advance Your claim.
You agree that You are expressly authorizing the Firms (and any party acting on behalf of the Firms) to contact You at the mobile phone numbers You have provided and may provide to Us in the future. You agree that the Firm may use automatic telephone dialing systems in connection with text messages sent to Your phone. You will promptly notify the Firms in the event You change Your phone number(s). Your consent to receive text messages, SMS, and WhatsApp cannot be revoked unless in writing to the Firms, by sending an electronic message to Us. You understand that Your consent is not a condition of receiving legal services.
If Your claim results in a settlement or resolution, You agree that any sums due to You under the terms of this Agreement may be held in a client trust account until they are disbursed to You under the terms of any settlement or resolution
- Third Parties Bound.
This Agreement binds Your heirs, executors, administrators, successors, and assignees. In the event of Your death, it will bind any duly appointed representative of Your heirs or estate to the extent allowed by applicable law. In particular, any such representative will be bound by the provisions of this Agreement relating to the recovery of attorneys’ fees and costs and other expenses from any settlement entered into by You prior to Your death.
- Dispute Resolution.
NOTICE: This Agreement contains provisions requiring arbitration of fee disputes. Before You sign this Agreement, You should consult with another lawyer about the advisability of making an Agreement with mandatory arbitration requirements. Arbitration proceedings are ways to resolve disputes without use of the court system. By entering into agreements that require arbitration as the way to resolve fee disputes, You give up (waive) Your right to go to court to resolve those disputes by a judge or jury. There are important rights that should not be given up without careful consideration.
You agree to give Us thirty (30) days’ notice of any dispute by sending a letter or email to Us. If You and the Firms cannot resolve the dispute through direct discussions, both parties agree to first try to settle the dispute by mediation administered by the American Arbitration Association under its Consumer Mediation Procedures. If You and the Firms cannot resolve the dispute then, any disagreements will be settled by arbitration administered by the American Arbitration Association in accordance with its Consumer Arbitration Rules and judgment on the award rendered by the arbitrator(s) may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. The arbitration shall be governed by the laws of the State of Arizona. Unless both You and We agree otherwise, the arbitration will be based on the submission of documents or, if the arbitrator so directs, by remote or other electronic communication, and there shall be no in-person or oral hearing.
All claims must be brought in Your individual capacity, and not as a plaintiff or class member in any purported class, collective action, or representative proceeding. The arbitrator may not consolidate more than one person’s claims or engage in any class arbitration.
An arbitration resolves a dispute before one or more arbitrators and not a jury of one’s peers. Unlike a court proceeding, an arbitration proceeding is conducted in private, and the outcome will remain confidential. The arbitrators will have no authority to award punitive or other damages not measured by the prevailing party’s actual damages, except as may be required by statute. The standard provisions of the Consumer Rules shall apply. A judicial forum generally does not permit reasonable attorneys’ fees to be imposed against a non-prevailing client in a nonfrivolous action, and arbitrators will only have the authority to allocate attorneys’ fees if a particular law permits them to do so. Arbitrators will have the authority to allocate the costs of the arbitration process among the parties to the arbitration. By agreeing to mediation and arbitration, You and We waive the right to seek remedies in court, including the right to jury trial, the right to broad discovery, and the right to appeal. The benefits of mediation and arbitration are that they are less costly for You and Us, and they take less time than actions take in court. If You require additional information about the differences between a matter resolved through arbitration rather than through a judicial proceeding, please contact Us in writing. You also have the right to seek independent counsel to advise You before agreeing to this Agreement.
- Confidentiality.
You agree not to oppose any reasonable protective or sealing order We may seek in any arbitration or court proceeding to preserve the confidentiality of the proceeding including, but not limited to, Our client information, litigation strategies or work product, or confidential procedures and practices.
- No Other Lawyers.
You represent to Us that You have not signed an agreement with any other lawyers to pursue claims against the Company. If You do not remember signing such an agreement, but You did, by signing this Agreement You terminate that prior agreement and permit Us to contact and communicate with the other law firm about all issues related to Your claims against the Company.
- Headings.
The headings in this Agreement are for reference purposes only and do not have any effect on the meaning or interpretation of this Agreement.
- Severability; Freely Entered Into; Entire Agreement; Controlling Law.
You agree that if any provision or part of this Agreement is found to be invalid or unenforceable, only that particular provision or part, and not the entire Agreement, will be inoperative; and the invalidity of a particular provision in a particular jurisdiction shall not invalidate such provision in any other jurisdiction.
You confirm that You have entered into this Agreem ent, including the dispute resolution provision, freely and willingly and have had the opportunity to consult with attorneys of Your choice, other advisors, family, or friends about doing so.
This Agreement shall be governed and controlled by the laws of the State of Arizona, except its choice of laws provisions, and by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct.
ATTORNEY DOCUMENT AUTHORIZATION
By signing below You have authorized Don Bivens PLLC and The Bruno Firm, LLC (the “Firms”) to act as Your legal counsel in connection with claims that You have against Best Buy and certain additional parties. You authorize the Firms to obtain, in Your name and on Your behalf, any information or documents that may be contained in any file, private or public, pertaining to Your dispute with Best Buy, including information or documents held by Best Buy or third parties. This authorization is valid during such time as the Firms shall continue to act as Your counsel in connection with such claims.
BY SIGNING BELOW, I HEREBY CONFIRM AND AGREE TO THE TERMS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING, AS IF MY ORIGINAL SIGNATURE WAS ON EACH:
ATTORNEY-CLIENT RETAINER AGREEMENTAND ATTORNEY DOCUMENT AUTHORIZATION.
SIGNED BY:
Don Bivens PLLC
15169 N. Scottsdale Road, Suite 205
Scottsdale, Arizona 85254
SIGNED BY:
The Bruno Firm, LLC
205 N. Michigan Avenue, Suite 810
Chicago, Illinois 60601