Message from Maxwell Weiss, Esq:
Hello and thank you for your interest in this case. I’m Maxwell Weiss, an attorney who
represents clients in a variety of different types of lawsuits across the country. I am currently a
partner at Don Bivens PLLC, and I specialize in representing injured parties in class actions and
mass arbitrations, with a particular emphasis on privacy, labor and employment, ERISA,
securities, and sexual-abuse cases. I would like to take this opportunity to outline the retention
agreement you will be signing, should you wish to participate as a claimant in this arbitration. If
you have any questions after reviewing this recording or would like to schedule a fifteen minute
consultation with myself or another Don Bivens attorney, please contact us at  bbinfo@donbivens.com 602-762-2661
By signing the retention agreement, you are retaining myself, the law firm of Don Bivens PLLC,
and The Bruno Firm, LLC (collectively referred to as “the Firms”, or “we”) as counsel to
represent you for the purposes of pursuing claims against Best Buy Co. Inc. and any other
related parties for potential legal violations related to your private information being unlawfully
disclosed by Best Buy.
You’re also authorizing the Firms to represent you in related claims against Best Buy that they
may discover and determine are feasible to pursue on your behalf. It’s important to note that the
Firms do not represent you in any other matters unless we sign a separate agreement
governing those matters. The Firms will represent you to the best of their ability and according
to their ethical duties as lawyers.
The retention agreement provides your rights and responsibilities as a claimant and the terms of
our joint representation of you in this action. Please note that this message is a summary of the
agreement, not the agreement itself. We ask that you please read the agreement carefully, and
if you have any questions, you can also reach out to my firm by emailing
bbinfo@donbivens.com or calling 602-762-2661. You of course also have the right to consult
with independent counsel for legal advice before entering into this agreement.
I will now go through the retention agreement to explain its key terms. Please note that my
explanation does not include every term, and we ask that you read the entire agreement
carefully. Understanding the agreement is essential, as it guides our work together in pursuing
your claims.
Scope of Representation
First, let’s talk about what it means for you to retain our services.
By signing this agreement, you’re giving us the authority to take several actions on your behalf
to pursue your claims. These actions include sending a demand letter to Best Buy, filing an
individual arbitration claim, engaging in settlement discussions on your behalf, and potentially
pursing this matter as a class action in civil court. You also authorize the Firms to potentially
execute an opt-out of any class action settlement. This range of options gives us flexibility to
choose the approach that is in your best interests.
The Firms may prepare and sign legal documents and obtain necessary documents from Best
Buy or third parties to evaluate and pursue your claim and negotiate potential settlements. You
authorize the Firms to reject any settlement offers that are not equal to your actual loss or the
maximum allowable damages, whichever is greater, unless we believe we have achieved the
best settlement possible under the circumstances. However, we will not settle your claim without
your consent, and you will have the right to accept or reject any settlement offer that we present
to you from Best Buy.
If an arbitrator or other fact finder does not rule in your favor, we will evaluate the possibility of
appealing the decision if allowed to do so. While we may determine at our sole discretion not to
pursue an appeal, we will always inform you so you may protect any appeal rights that you have
independently.
You will not be the only client the Firms are representing with respect to this claim, and you
acknowledge that representation of multiple clients may give rise to potential conflicts of
interest. If we believe that such a conflict exists, we will discuss it with you. If we have to
withdraw from representing you, you agree to waive any objection to representing other clients
in this matter.
The agreement also touches upon the unpredictable and risky nature of legal disputes. The
outcome of disputed legal matters is always uncertain. We cannot guarantee that this claim will
be successful or that you will recover any money or obtain any other form of relief.
Attorneys’ Fees and Costs
Now, let’s move on to attorneys’ fees and costs. One of the most important parts of the
agreement is understanding how fees and costs work in this case, especially since we’re
representing you on a contingency basis. This means you’ll pay no fees upfront, and the Firms’
fees will depend on the outcome.
To explain further, attorneys’ fees are not set by law — they are instead based on an agreement
between by the attorneys and their clients. By signing the retention agreement, you are
choosing a contingency payment arrangement, instead of paying fees as they are incurred. This
means you will pay no retainer fee for this matter, and the Firms’ fee for professional services
will be contingent on the results obtained. You authorize the Firms to handle this case and to
negotiate any possible settlement as to both your recovery and the attorney fees.
When we negotiate settlements in these cases, we’ll be discussing both your damages and our
attorney fees with Best Buy. While this type of negotiation is standard practice, we want to be
transparent about how we calculate the total compensation you may receive. We start with what
we call the “total gross recovery” – that’s the total amount recovered before any deductions. The
total compensation you will receive will be this total gross recovery minus our attorney fees and
certain costs, which I’ll now explain in more detail.
For representing you in this case, you are agreeing that the Firms’ contingency fee will be equal
to one of the following: a) forty percent (40%) of the total gross recovery obtained on your
behalf, unless the law in your state limits contingency fees to a lower percentage; b) if
specifically designated in a settlement or judgment, all attorneys’ fees, costs, and expenses; or
c) all amounts of recovery in excess of the full per-client statutory damages to which you may be
entitled under applicable law You will not owe us any attorneys’ fees unless we successfully
collect a financial recovery for you. Under our agreement, which of these options we elect is at
the Firms’ discretion. Let’s walk through each option.
The first option is 40% of total gross recovery obtained on your behalf. For example, if the total
gross recovery is $100,000, the attorneys’ fees would be $40,000, with the remaining $60,000
going to the clients, divided on a per-claim basis. Please note that this example is illustrative
only and doesn’t reflect any specific recovery amount that may be likely in this case. If there is
no recovery, you will not be required to pay any attorneys’ fees.
The second option is whatever amount is specifically designated in a settlement or judgment. A
settlement with the Defendant on your behalf could specifically identify how much of the
settlement is designated to attorneys’ fees. This would be deducted from the total gross
recovery, with the remainder being provided to you.
The third option is the Firms receiving the excess of the full statutory per-client damages.
Sometimes, the law provides a fixed amount of damages that a type of violation by a Defendant
is worth. In these claims against Best Buy, the relevant fixed quantity is $2,500. So, for example,
if the Court awards you $10,000 in damages you would receive $2,500 and the Firms would
receive $7,500. Again, this is only an illustrative example and does not reflect any specific
recovery amount that may be likely in this case.
I should also mention something about what is called statutory fees. Some laws may require
Best Buy to pay your attorneys’ fees and costs if your claim is successful, called statutory fees.
If these laws apply, we will seek to recover these statutory fees directly from Best Buy. If these
statutory fees end up being higher than our standard 40% contingency fee, we will take the
statutory fees instead of the contingency fee, which could allow you to keep more of your
compensation.
My firm and The Bruno Firm agree that if this case results in any award of attorneys’ fees, the
total fees will be divided between the two firms, with 25% going to Don Bivens PLLC and 75%
going to The Bruno Firm. We believe that this division of attorneys’ fees is reasonable in light of
the anticipated responsibilities of the two firms, and in light of the need to represent you
competently and diligently. The division of responsibility is as follows: The Bruno Firm will serve
as lead counsel in your representation with principal responsibility for strategic decisions, while
Don Bivens PLLC has played a larger role in marketing and vetting qualified clients and claims
and will also advise The Bruno Firm on all major aspects of the case.
The agreement also addresses the expenses of pursuing your claim. Generally, expenses can
include, for example, filing costs and fees, charges for photocopies, postage, expert witness
fees, transcription fees, mediation and arbitration costs and fees, messenger services, and
travel expenses. If there is a gross recovery, you will be informed in writing of the amount of the
expenses to be deducted from your recovery at cost after attorneys’ fees have been calculated.
For example, let’s assume that the Firms elect for the contingency fee of 40% upon a successful
recovery. If the total gross recovery is $100,000, and the lawyers incurred $1,000 in costs, the
Firms would be paid the 40% contingent fee plus those costs, or $41,000, and the clients would
receive $59,000. Again, this example is for illustration only and does not reflect any expected
recovery amount in this case. If there is no recovery, you will not be required to pay these
expenses.
Because this case involves the Firms representing multiple clients with similar claims, we may
negotiate a group settlement with Best Buy that covers several claims at once. If we receive a
group settlement payment as a lump sum, we will divide it equitably among all clients whose
claims are part of that settlement. The same principle applies to any shared expenses – we will
distribute these costs fairly among the clients who benefit from them
Client Responsibilities
We’ve talked about our role and responsibilities to you, so now let’s touch on some of your
responsibilities as a client. Working together effectively helps us build the strongest case
possible.
Your most important responsibility to be truthful with the Firms at all times. It is also crucial that
you promptly respond to the Firms’ communications with you, including requests for information
or documents necessary to move your claim forward. You must also notify us in writing of any
changes to your address, telephone, or other contact information.
If you fail to cooperate with us, if you don’t follow our advice, or if you fail to comply with the
agreement, we may withdraw our representation of you. Please note that the agreement also
sets out other circumstances in we may withdraw our representation, including where we
believe that pursuing your claim will be extremely difficult or expensive, or where you reject a
settlement offer that we advise is in your best interests. We will provide you with reasonable
notice before withdrawing representation.
Regarding communications, you are expressly authorizing the Firms (and any party acting on
their behalf) to contact you at the mobile phone numbers you provide. This includes text
messages SMS and WhatsApp, and we may use automatic telephone dialing systems for these
communications.
By signing the agreement, you are representing that you have not signed an agreement with
any other lawyers to pursue claims against Best Buy, or that if you do not remember doing that
but you did, you terminate that earlier agreement and allow us to contact the other lawyers
about your claim.
Dispute Resolution
Lastly, I want to touch on how matters will be resolved if you and the Firms have any dispute
about this Agreement or our services, including about the fees. Hopefully, disputes won’t arise
between us, but it’s important to know that the agreement includes a clear dispute resolution
process.
If there is a dispute, we will first try to settle it through direct discussions. You will give the Firms
30 days’ notice by sending a letter or email to us, and if we can’t resolve matters through direct
discussions, both parties agree to first try to settle the dispute by mediation administered by the
American Arbitration Association under its Consumer Mediation Procedures.
If mediation is unsuccessful, any disagreements will be settled by individual arbitration. This will
be administered by the American Arbitration Association in accordance with its Consumer
Arbitration Rules. Arbitration is a way to resolve disputes without use of the court system or
juries, and instead before an arbitrator or arbitrators. The benefits of mediation and arbitration
are that they are less costly for you and for us, they take less time than actions take in court,
and they are confidential and private. However, it is important to understand that with arbitration,
you will also be giving up certain rights, including the right to a jury trial, broad discovery, and
appeals.
Thank you for taking the time to listen to this explanation. I encourage you to read the
agreement carefully and you can always contact us for further consultation if you have any
questions. As a reminder, you can do so by reaching out to bbinfo@donbivens.com or 602-762-2661 and a Don
Bivens attorney will respond and advise. And remember, you’re also welcome to consult
independent counsel before entering into this agreement.